Is our email safe from the invoice scam?

The short answer

The invoice scam works when somebody is quietly reading your email and waiting for a real payment to be discussed. Two habits stop most of it: a second step on every login, and a rule that any change of bank details gets confirmed by phoning a number you already had. Neither one costs much to put in place.

A business owner on the telephone by a window, notebook in hand

How it actually runs

It starts with one password. Reused on another site that was breached, typed into a convincing sign-in page, or simply guessable. Nothing happens for weeks after that, which is the part owners find hardest to believe. Somebody reads. They learn who approves payments, who your suppliers are, and how your invoices are worded.

Then they set a quiet mail rule that files certain replies into an unused folder, so the conversation only reaches them. They wait for a real invoice to come up. The message that arrives looks ordinary, mentions the right project, and carries new banking details, sometimes from a domain one letter different from the real one. The money leaves on a Friday.

Signs somebody is already in the mailbox

Replies that people swear they sent and you never saw. Mail rules or forwarding you did not create. Items in the sent folder you do not remember writing. A supplier asking about a message nobody at your end wrote. A sign-in alert from a place none of your staff has been.

Any one of those is worth an hour of somebody’s attention today. They are far cheaper to check than to explain to your bank later.

What actually stops it

A second step on every login, including the owner’s and the bookkeeper’s. This one control ends most stolen-password attacks on its own, because the password stops being enough.

An alert whenever a new mail rule or forwarding address is created, so the quiet part of the attack makes a noise.

The three settings on your domain that make it harder for anyone to send mail that looks like it came from you. They go by the initials SPF, DKIM and DMARC, they are configured once, and your staff never see them.

Registering the two or three obvious lookalike versions of your domain, so nobody else can.

A written payment rule: no change of bank details is acted on from an email alone, ever, and confirmation happens by phoning a number you already had on file. Tell the people who pay invoices, in plain terms, that slowing a payment down will never get them in trouble.

The first hour, if money already moved

Call your bank and ask for a recall immediately, because the chance of getting funds back falls away by the hour. Change the password on the mailbox and sign every session out, so the reading stops. Check the mail rules and remove the ones you did not create. Keep the messages exactly as they are, headers included, since they are the evidence.

Then tell your insurer, tell whoever else was in the conversation, and check whether any other mailbox in the office shows the same signs. A person here calls you back the same business day, usually within an hour, and can work the list with you.

What we would do

On email, the first pass on a new client’s office covers this.

  • Turn on a second login step for every account, starting with the owner, the bookkeeper and anyone who can approve a payment.
  • Audit the existing mail rules and forwarding on every mailbox, and report anything already in place.
  • Set the domain records that make your name harder to imitate, and monitor them.
  • Alert us and you when a new rule, forwarding address or admin account appears.
  • Write the payment-change rule into a single page your staff can actually follow, and brief them on it.
  • Keep a plan for the bad day, so nobody has to work out who to call while the money is moving.

This work sits inside the monthly fee. The published prices for each plan are on the pricing page.

Two more questions people ask next

All the answers

Ask us to check your mailboxes.

Leave your name and your number. A person calls you back the same business day, usually within an hour. If you think something is happening right now, say so and your request goes to the front of the queue.

Ask us to call you back

Leave your name and number. A real person calls you back the same business day, usually within an hour.

We use your number to call you back about your request. Nothing else.

Call me back